The most popular beard products ever made are the beard oil and the beard balm or balsam.
But which one is better when you compare them head to head, and should you choose one over another or perhaps use them both?
Table of Contents
Beard Balm vs. Beard Oil Explained
So what exactly makes beard oil different from beard balm?
Well, the consistency for starters. The balm contains some natural beeswax and is solid in room temperature. You need to scoop some out and heat in-between your fingers before you apply it.
Beard oil, will always remain in liquid form, simply because it has no beeswax in the formulation.
Other than the solid consistency, there are also small differences in the blends of carrier and essential oils.
Beard balms are often higher in topical fats like coconut oil and shea butter, which provide nourishment to the deep skin layers but have the downfall of also being so thick and heavy that they can block the pores.
These have slightly worse hydrating benefits, but they do not clog the pores and absorb much better than balms do.
Bottom line: If you want something unnoticeable that softens the beard and prevents facial hair itchiness, get beard oil. And if you need something less unnoticeable that truly moisturizes and nourishes the skin – and helps to eliminate beard dandruff – consider using beard balm.
Key Benefits of Using Beard Oil
The purpose of beard oil is to help you replace the natural sebum oils that you lose when you shower and wash your face.
Since the sebaceous glands that produce the oils are finite in size, the longer your beard gets, the more beard oil you need to use.
If you fail to do this, and your beard grows long without using any beard oil at all, you will inevitably struggle with dry, brittle, and itchy facial hair.
However, if you use beard oil your beard will stay soft and well-moisturized.
Here’s a quick list of the key beard oil benefits:
- Replaces sebum oils you lose when showering.
- Moisturizes the beard hair fibers from within.
- Naturally softens and conditions the beard.
- Can slightly help prevent beard dandruff.
- Reduces beard itches, redness, and rashes.
- Makes your facial hair look more healthy and vibrant.
Remember that you don’t really need beard oil until your beard reaches about 1.5″ to 2″ in length. Before that, the natural sebum oil produced by the sebaceous glands will be plenty enough.
Key Benefits of Using Beard Balm
The main purpose of beard balm is to protect and deep condition the facial hair.
It could be called the heavy-weight version of beard oil, and that would be pretty close.
Where beard balm really shines is when you have already let your beard go into a bad condition. It has gotten dry, brittle, and there are flakes of dandruff on it.
In those cases, beard oil may simply not be enough anymore, and you need some extra hydrating benefits. And that’s when you grab a beard balm.
Since there’s some beeswax in the formulation, many men also use beard balm to style, shape, and tame their beards. For that purpose, it’s much more useful than the liquidy beard oils.
In short, these are the key benefits of beard balm:
- Effectively prevents beard dandruff.
- Reduces beard itching and rash quickly.
- Protects the facial hair from the elements (cold, humidity, etc).
- Gives some extra volume and weight to your facial hair.
- Helps you in styling and taming the beard.
- Can make your beard look healthier and shinier.
The only bad thing about beard balms is that it’s so heavy and thick that it can block the pores and look a bit greasy on the face.
Which One Should I Use?
Since we are nerds about our own beard care routine here, of course, we are going to recommend that you use both the beard oil and the beard balm.
The reason being that they offer unique benefits which differ greatly from another – even though many see them as almost identical products.
If you insist on us choosing the better one, we would have to side with beard oil having a little bit more uses.
Let’s say you can only select beard oil or beard balm as your go-to beard care product, then you need to choose the product that better suits your needs…
- For itchy and dry beards, that need to be made softer naturally, beard oil is a better solution.
- For super-dry and dandruffy beards that are in need of some extra nourishment, beard balm will always be better.
- But if you truly want the best of both World’s, then apply the oil after a shower, and follow up with the balm 2-4 hours later.
Why after the shower? What’s the secret behind that?
Beard oil was originally formulated to replace the natural sebum oils that you lose when you wash your face.
Therefore it’s only natural to apply it immediately after the shower and as an added benefit this way you will be sealing some of the moisture from that shower into your facial hair fibers as well.
If you then follow up with the beard balm a few hours later, you can enhance the benefits of the oil as the beeswax in the balm will create an ultra-thin lipid layer on top of your beard which works as a protective barrier that further seals in the moisture.
Should you choose beard oil or beard balm?
We say you should get them both, and if that isn’t an option, maybe start from getting the beard oil and see if you need to upgrade to balms later on.
They both have their unique benefits, even though if you look at the ingredients, they are not too different from each other.
I guess you could sum it all up by saying that beard balm is just a heavy-duty beeswax-infused version of beard oil.